The linesman on the penalty should be booked, like player do when they get red cards.
This is an important game for Man Utd and they would probably win anyway, but still my guts are telling me powerful bookers might have their hands in some games. BTW this is just speculations and every linesman can make a mistake :)
Hope to see some mature comments about this. Thanks.

So what United been lucky for EVERY GAME the whole season? and seasons before that? You know what it boils down to in the end? Selective f*****king memory. Thats what AAAAAAll haters have. Three games (Chelsea, Fulham, QPR) through out this season where united got the calls ruling there way and the world of haters accumulate short term memory of the games Manchester United worked HAAAARD for. They fully DESERVED it.
GGMU
Cheers.

i always get the feelings that man u supporters are the most arrogant fans in the game..Now it transferred to player also..see what ashley did..disgrace..Even though they are going to win the league with the help of referee,they are not worth it..

So Im seeing here fans saying s**t like, 'Fergie is s**t,' Man United are cheaters.' Here is what I say.
1. Arsenal fans (8-2 and 2-1) Lucky game?
2. Liverpool Fans (1-1 and 2-1) Lucky game?
3. Tottenham Fans (3-0 and 3-1) Lucky game?
The only fans who have all right to spit are Chelsea, Newcastle and City fans.
To bad the majority fans who are the sore losers are the ones UNITED burned HAHAHAHAHA

Haters are always gonna look for ways to hate!! I say eff u all !! Bet it must feel really painful when they see us win trophies after trophies. whilst your club can only watch and wish!!. It must suck eh? I feel sorry for u all cause it must hurt like a bitch to see us win again and again despite ur wishes lol It's just sad to see people come up with silly excuses like this time after time when statistics clearly shows otherwise. You lot are just bitter individuals that will never change, what a shame. Shame on you all!!! I'm not normally the kind to boast about anything but seems a lot of people are forgetting that we are a top side and win majority of our games because we stronger and not cause of human error. I could go on but u kno what i'm just gonna bother. peace

What a dive. Someone break young's legs.

I say they start replaying stuff like this on the big screen before the refs make a decision cuz this is bullshittt

It's amazing how people on remember the decisions that go in United's favour and never the many that go against us, when a ref makes a bad decision for us, we've paid him, he supports United, we're cheaters who win the title with the ref's help.. When a ref makes a bad decision against us, you all crawl back under your rocks and take off your troll masks just waiting for the nesxt decision in our favour... Take a look back in your clubs history and you tell comment back, honestly saying that the refs have absolutely NEVER gone in your favour...

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/17663750
complete bullshit

Scholes, Scholes, he scores goals!

I'm completely neutral, but that was maybe the worst PK call I've ever seen! The guy was a mile offside, he takes a blatant dive & not only the ref gives a pen, but sends the defender off?!!! Absolutely disgusting officiating.

"man utd is a cheater" okay fine, "your team is favored by the referee" okay fine, "man utd plays dirty football" yeah whatever you say bro, now can i say something?
"go head".... alright, our team is going to win the EPL title for the 20th times and i will really enjoy it, can you? ahhh not that look again, okay go clean my shoes and i'll help you buy an ice cream tomorrow, alright? now have a good day :)

Nice goal by Scholes. As for the penalty kick, if it hadn't been offside it would have been ok to give it. You just can't split the world of penalty kicks into brutal fouls and "diving" only. There's a lot of cases where the defender does commit a foul and the attacker greatly exaggerates the effect. Even if that's not exactly a message to the kids from Ashley Young, what's the ref gonna do? He can't ignore the foul because Young makes a show of it. And Derry did push him from behind to interfere with his run, it's not like he was going for the ball or even had any chance to. It's a deliberate push and perfectly unrelated to getting the ball, only aiming to get Young off balance. He was asking for it.

That said, of course it WAS offside.

if everyone honestly here thinks man utd would have lost or drew to QPR even if they had 11 players is stupid. Man Utd are on form and from beggining of game they were dominating plus QPR looked like they were just satisfied with getting a point, plus how are they supoosed to beat man utd without SWP, Barton, Cisse, Zamora? that team was too weak. and yeah ashley young did go down soft but even if it was a dive or not there was contact and running at his speed and weight a touch could knock him down, now look at players like drogba who are really strong and go down like its nothing. i still agree derry shouldnt have got a red nor a penalty for us but either way we were gonna score.

"Same ol' United, always cheating."

An offside, dive and a red card. I really wonder how Derry just strolled off calmly and accepted it. Admire him for that.