I hate how people get on here and say the score should have been more and that Villa should have won by more goals, who CARES??? They won, whether or not more goals should have stood or whatever, by my book a win is a win, am I wrong? Don't get caught up with the scoreline, just enjoy the fact that you won! If you had drawn or lost then talk, but not after a win!

i like the "talking points" bent was definitely offside, and barton definitely fouled young. how are those debatable?

Petrov was the best player on the pitch in this match! 10/10

good work aston villla!!

I love how Joey Barton thinks he's better than Wilshere and Gerard, absolutely hilarious

Why do the bbc leave out important key moments like the Villa penalty shout?

Two poor sides. Bad day at the office for Newcastle, the injuries and suspensions just took their toll.

Man that's a nice header by collins!

Wow newcastle got lucky with this game. it should have been 3-1.

Gutierrez should have put a through ball to Barton right at 1:59... watch barton's disbelief when he doesn't recieve a cross...

well, this is a very good result for gerard houlier and his relegation pressured aston villa. good result. and in the end, a very important 3 points for villa.

This should have been a draw, or 2-1 as the offside was very marginal bloody ranger, lovenkrands was open and had heaps of space to put the ball into, how come he can score 5 goals in seven games for U19's and be that bad for NUFC.

A well deserved win for Aston Villa.
Newcastle's away kits look decent!

Blatant penalty... what on earth is Saylor doing!? liability!

iam sad