Manchester City

Teams /  England  / Manchester City 
Manchester City have 2,766 Fans
Matthew Etherington's injury-time equaliser denies Manchester City
Joe Lovejoy at Britannia Stadium - 3 years ago

The Northern Softies did not deserve to win, but seemed to have done so when Micah Richards scored his first goal for 10 months. Unfortunately for Roberto Mancini and his fairweather team, stout-hearted Stoke are never beaten until the final whistle and deservedly equalised two minutes into added time through Matthew Etherington.

Manchester City took one look at the Britannia tundra and emerged with gloves on. Tony Pulis and company are made of sterner stuff and had their sleeves rolled up, metaphorically at least. In the first half, Mancini's foreigners were in dilettante mode, going about their work as if they would rather be anywhere else. The City manager sought to excuse them on the dubious basis that it was "difficult" to play football on a less than perfect surface and against Stoke's "long ball, long ball, long ball."

It was a spurious argument. Manchester United and Tottenham have both won here, and teams with title aspirations need to overcome such obstacles if they are to be taken seriously.

The goals were a long time coming, but both were well worth waiting for.

Playing his ninth game of the season only because Pablo Zabaleta was suspended, Richards received from James Milner in the inside-right channel, where he executed the sweetest of turns to lose Danny Collins before shooting with cool precision into the far corner. The finish came as a reminder that, at 22, the former England right-back still has time on his side when it comes to adding to his 12 caps.

Stoke's equally smart equaliser was set up by Tuncay's lovely sleight of foot, the Turk's clever backheel letting in Etherington on the left, from where the winger beat Joe Hart with slide-rule precision. Long ball dross? Hardly.

Stoke were unchanged in pursuit of a fourth consecutive win, Mancini made three changes after the 4-1 victory at Fulham. Richards for Zabaleta was one, the others saw Milner back for Yaya Touré, who was injured, and Mario Balotelli restored up front. Jô, relegated to the bench, got on at the death, providing the collectors' item Jô [90].

City were palsied in the first half, and Mancini's claim that they had "played very well and deserved to win" was ludicrous. As Pulis observed: "What game was he watching?"

Thirty-five minutes had elapsed before City produced their first worthwhile strike at goal. In contrast, Stoke were constantly on the front foot and threatened regularly. Their persistence would have been rewarded had Ricardo Fuller summoned the accuracy an inviting through pass from Kenwyne Jones merited. Fuller, Etherington and Jermaine Pennant all spurned decent opportunities in the first half, prompting Pulis to say: "At the interval I was desperately disappointed not to be winning the game. When you're playing against one of the best teams in the league, you have to take your chances, and that's one thing we need to improve."

City improved in the second half, but Stoke defended with steely determination and might have taken the lead after 77 minutes when Milner blocked Jones's close-range contact on the goalline. It was City who did score four minutes later, but the Blue Moonies started singing too soon. Justice was done with Etherington's second goal of the season.

Helped by a translator, Mancini whinged nonsensically, leaving it to Pulis to supply a fitting summary.

The no-nonsense Welshman said: "You can have all the money in the world, and the top players, but a team playing against you as a team ? playing as one ? takes a lot of beating."

THE FANS' PLAYER RATINGS AND VERDICTCHRIS BALDWIN, When they scored, most people probably thought, "Well, that's it" but we kept going. It would have been a shame not to get anything out of the game because we deserved to be winning at halftime. A draw was a fair result, although if we'd taken our first half chances we might have sneaked it. Whitehead and Shawcross had good games and Pennant played really well. It was a shame he went off. I think that was one of the reasons it changed second half. I was half-expecting a goal when they scored, as they'd been pressing. Man City are a good side but it's difficult to come to Stoke - plenty of teams have proved that.

The fan's player ratings Begovic 7; Wilkinson 7 (Wilson 63 6), Huth 6, Shawcross 8, Collins 6; Pennant 7 (Tuncay 46 7), Whitehead 8, Delap 6, Etherington 7; Jones 6, Fuller 7 (Walters 75 6)

ENA PARKINSON, Observer reader The problem with following City is that it's angels and demons. You go to Fulham and destroy them, then in the first half today they were banging into each other as if they've never played together. You still don't know which City side will turn up. Look at Richards. Having scored a brilliant goal, he then became a demon with a stupid, unnecessary tackle that resulted in the free-kick that brought their goal. We really missed Zabaleta today, but Silva is a magician. Someone said to me last week, 'Let's see how he does at Stoke' and he IS tiny, but he wasn't bullied off the ball. He'd be the first one on my teamsheet every week - even before Tevez.

The fan's player ratings Hart 5; Richards 4, Toure 5, Kompany 6, Kolarov 6; Silva 7, De Jong 6, Barry 5, Milner 3 (Johnson 82 n/a); Tevez 7, Balotelli 5 (Jo 89 n/a)

To take part in the Fans' Verdict, email

This is not a news report and may contain views expressed by the author which are not supported by GNM.

Share your thoughts
Sign in to comment

Latest News, Blogs & Podcasts

Manchester City's Albert Rusnak hopes to stay on loan at Cambuur Leeuwarden until the end of the season but admits the decision is out of his hands.
MCFC News - 47 minutes ago
The first Etihad Player of the Month award has gone to Stevan Jovetic.
MCFC News - 49 minutes ago
Our under-19s kick off their second UEFA Youth League campaign in the city they played their final group game last season.
The World Cup star is keen to get the chance to play alongside the influential midfielder and has set his sights on Champions League glory
The German side are hoping to rediscover their spark against Manchester City in the Champions League on Wednesday and ease the painful memory of their Real Madrid nadir Bayern fail to impress against  ...
James Milner believes Manchester City are now ready to compete on the European stage ahead of their opening UEFA Champions League group game.
MCFC News - 2 hours ago
City's fourth UEFA Champions League campaign gets under way at the Allianz Arena on Wednesday night at 19:45 (BST).
MCFC News - 3 hours ago
Fernandinho believes if City can take points off Bayern Munich both away and at home, progression to the last 16 will be almost guaranteed.
Pep Guardiola's side are set to be without several key players for the visit of Manuel Pellegrini's Premier League champions
MCFC News - 5 hours ago
Bayern Munich midfielder Xabi Alonso believes his team will be facing one of the best teams in Europe when City arrive at the Allianz tomorrow evening.
MCFC News - 5 hours ago
James Milner says City must ensure the Etihad Stadium is a fortress during the 2014/15 Champions League campaign - but says there is no reason why last season's 3-2 win in Munich can't be repeated.
Manchester City will go from sky blue to an 'electric' blend of dark purple on their travels this season, as the club release a new strip for away cup games
Manchester City - 13 hours ago
Midfielder James Milner believes Manchester City are now capable of making a big impression in the Champions League.
Manchester City - 14 hours ago
Midfielder James Milner believes Manchester City are now capable of making a big impression in the Champions League.
I think we have a team good enough to win City lost 3-1 Bayern Munich in corresponding match last yearJames Milner is clear that Manchester City have to prove themselves in the Champions League, with  ...
MCFC News - 17 hours ago
Be one of the first to own the new 2014/15 cup away kit by pre-ordering online at or instore.
MCFC News - 20 hours ago
A host of City’s loan stars impressed and several scored important goals for their respective teams over the weekend.
Martin Demichelis feels he has another year of top-level football in him and is hoping to land a new deal at Manchester City.
MCFC News - Yesterday
Manchester City stars Willy Caballero and Dedryck Boyata are getting behind City in the Community’s gang awareness project ‘City Streets’.
Arjen Robben doubtful for Champions League opener Alcantara, Schweinsteiger, Rafinha and Badstuber out Bayern fail to impress in victory over Stuttgart Raphael Honigstein talks to Thomas MüllerBayern ...

Latest Photo Galleries

Manchester City v Manchester United: in pictures
3 years ago
Our award-winning photographer Tom Jenkins is at the game to bring you all the action from the first Manchester derby of the season
In pictures - Liverpool v Napoli and Lech Poznan v Manchester City
3 years ago
All the best images from tonight's Europa League matches featuring Liverpool and Manchester City
Manchester City v Arsenal in pictures
3 years ago
Tom Jenkins's best pictures from today's clash at Eastlands
Kick4Life - changing lives through football