Forums / Manchester United
Order: Newest / Oldest
Player Ratings For 2010/11 Season
EnziWazza (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Out of 10 and may you can add some reason, what would you give each player for their contributions in 2010/11 season?

Vds -
Pig -

Vidic –
Evra -
O'Shea -
Evans -
Smalling -
Rafael -
Fabio -
Rio -
Brown * -

Carrick -
Anderson -
Giggs -
Scholes -
Gibson -
Valencia -
Nani -
Park -
Fletcher -

Obertan* -
Bebe* -

Rooney -
Berbatov -
Chicharito -
Owen -
RRajeev (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Hi mate.... Great discussion.... It would be good to add:  Saf -  Man UTD -
EnziWazza (Manchester United) 3 years ago
For SAF it's too big - 36
For Man UTD absolutely too big - 59 and will be 60 at May 28

I think we never rating manager and club, let history judge its

Btw thanks for your contribution )
Roo10ney (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Ya the history speaks for itself...
EnziWazza (Manchester United) 3 years ago
VDS – 8, 5 : still make unbelievable saving, as though we forget his age 40, he will retire as champion, really hope double champion
Pig – 5 : when he’s not playing, he’s look like had much spirit to get in pitch but when he’s playing he still showed lack of consistency, but he also didn’t get much chance

Vidic – 8, 5 : he tough as a rock and never give up, great captain
Evra – 7, 5 : some time he’s look to deep in opponent's area and always make trouble when he leave defence area with not cover from another player but still had more tackle than other
O'Shea – 6, 5 : when fergie need him he’s always ready though fans look unexpected, but he always doing well
Evans – 6, 5 : make some mistake when defeated against westham in carling cup, but looks more stronger in defence area than last season
Smalling – 7, 5 : he’s replacing rio job very well, fantastic first season for smalling
Rafael – 7 : very excited, always looking attack and very confident
Fabio – 7 : same with he’s brother, but he looks better when playing on the right side
Rio – 7, 5 : injury make he missed some important match but he’s come back on the right time, make our defence more stronger in champions league quarter final at stamford bridge till now
Brown* - 5 : poor contribution from him this season, cause he don’t get many chance than 2 last season, score 1 goal in FA cup as captain

Carrick – 7, 5 : he make opponent's attack get delayed, to make all team mate regroup in defence line, make fantastic crossing in champions league quarter final for ryan giggs when rooney scored
Anderson – 6, 5 : make some great contribution when get chance to play, although he’s not play in many game this season and score 2 goal in champions league semi final
Giggs – 7, 5 : better than last 2 season when ronaldo still in united, he’s always giving color for united game and he’s 37.... Super giggsy
Scholes – 6, 5 : not he’s best season, but still showing great short and long pass, no one can replace little genius
Gibson – 6 : hasn’t showed his prowess, get many chance than last season and make 1 good assist and 1 goal when beat Schalke in champions league semi
Valencia – 6, 5 : get bad injury, and come back with fantastic performance looks like he never get injured
Nani – 7, 5 : start this season very well make more assist than last season, make some great goal, but fade away in the end of season, hope can give big contribution in champions league final
Park – 7 : swiftly, had strong endurance, and always quick to get defence line and back to the opponent's defence area looks like he’s never stop running
Fletcher 6 – : not give much contribution, not see in top match this season, wish he can get his best performance again

Obertan* - 5 : can’t showed a high desire to played at top level
Bebe* - 4, 5 : same with obertan, but he can’t passing well, he can’t shoot to the post.... When he’s being hagro substitution he's also get replaced again with another player.... ’ lol

Rooney – 8 : failed in world cup and make some trouble at the beginning of the season, but still shine in the end and showed a high desire to play for united in a long time and give us 19st trophy with fantastic penalty against blackburn
Berbatov – 8 : make more goal (top score till now I hope he can get golden boots), I thinks this is his best season for united, beat liverpool with hattrick, make 2 goal to defeat blackpool when united down with 2 goal and score 1 goal at OT when defeat Bolton to secure 3 points is his best season moment and bad season moment when he missed goal twice in FA cup semifinal against shitty
Chicharito – 8 : fantastic first season for little pea, make some important winning goal, had more expectation from him in another game, shortly champion league final against barcelona
Owen – 5, 5 : don’t get many chance from boss, and averagely when he play not too bad

So no one get above 9 from me, cause no one showed prominent individual this season, this squad played with unity as a team
Maestro7 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Park should be 8 too!
EnziWazza (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Park Ji Sung statistic : appearances 23 (+ 3 as sub); goals 7; yellow cards 1, like I say before Man united play 57 match in all competition this season till may 14 : 37 premier league, 5 FA cup, 3 Carling Cup and 12 champion league.... He's not play much game this season specially in champion league.... For me he deserve 7 for his late goal against wolve and his one goal against arsenal at OT plus his best performance against chelsea
Kayteo (Manchester United) 3 years ago
I don't want to make a huge list, so I'll just pitch in a few....

Smalling 9 - without him we wouldn't be champions, he covered so well in defence for so many games when we needed him, even with brown as his partner he played well, amazing first season.

Vidic 9 - only two or three bad games all year, fantastic. Not as good a captain as Rio but he sure got the job done.

Chicharito 9 - some incredibly important goals.

The only player I'd rate poorly is Obertan, I expected a lot more from him this season but he never really looked up for it except against Villa away. I don't know what it will take for him to make the next step, he's talented but maybe he's not suited for left wing where he's been used most.
Rob12 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Vds - 9
Pig - 1

Vidic – 9
Evra - 7
O'Shea - 6
Evans - 5
Smalling - 6
Rafael - 7
Fabio - 6
Rio - 8
Brown * - 6

Carrick - 8
Anderson - 6
Giggs - 8
Scholes - 7
Gibson - 6
Valencia - Hardly played so can't rate him.
Nani - 8
Park - 8
Fletcher - 7

Obertan* - 4
Bebe* - 0

Rooney - 7
Berbatov - 8
Chicharito - 8
Owen - 5
Bladecatcher (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Smalling deserves more than a 6? He was great this season. I have high hopes for him
Rob12 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Yea but he hasn't played enough games to get a high rating
REDDevil98 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Same can be said with Brown to warrant him to get a 6
Bladecatcher (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Hmm fair enough. He's still done great in the games he has played in
Maestro7 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Great list but I agree that Smalling should be higher played 32 games this season tht should be enough.... Right?  
SoccerIsFootbal (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Vds - 9
Pig - 4

Vidic – 9
Evra - 8
O'Shea - 7. 5
Evans - 5
Smalling - 8
Rafael - 7. 5
Fabio - 6. 5
Rio - 8. 5
Brown * - 5

Carrick - 7. 5
Anderson - 6. 5
Giggs - 9
Scholes - 7. 5
Gibson - 6. 1
Valencia - 8
Nani - 8. 5
Park - 8
Fletcher - 7

Obertan* - 4
Bebe* - 3

Rooney - 8
Berbatov - 8. 25 would be higher if not for the fa cup semifinal.
Chicharito - 8. 5
Owen - 5. 5
RRajeev (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Vds - 9. 5- Why are you 40?
Pig - 5- He keeps asking for a chance, what happen when you got it?

Vidic – 9. 5- What happen when he don't play?
Evra - 6- I personally didn't find Evra proving himself this season, He keeping talking.... But this season, I'm not his fan
O'Shea - 7- Versatile, played LB, RB, DCM.... But gradually showing that he is tired.
Evans - 6- Not his best season, too many mistakes
Smalling - 7- What a player! Our big man.... Great purchase Sir!
Rafael - 7- Great start of the season, rated as one of the best young RB in the EPL, but again, injury in his way.
Fabio - 8- Finish his season with the first team place, didn't get his opportunity on the Left.... He came to replace his brother on the Right.
Rio - 7- Rio-injury prone.... That's what we know.... He is is really proving that he is one of the best defender in the EPL.
Brown * - 5- didn't play so much, But I know he scores and importan goal in the FA Cup.... Lol

Carrick - 8. 5- What if we didn't had him in out team this season? So patient, sat deep, great passer, He is important for MAN UTD.
Anderson - 8- He is out future and I think he proves that this season, injury again come in his way, but next season, this lad gona bring the power in attack.... His goals are coming....
Giggs - 9. 5- Give me a good reason why not to give him 9. 5?!.
Scholes - 6. 5- Started the season well, but I think its time to hang boots
Gibson - 6- He needs a loan deal.... Loan him to Bolton....
Valencia - 8- Gave him 8 because the way he make his comeback from an ankle injury, is so so awesome.
Nani - 8. 5- Best assist, a good season from him, after transfer rumours.
Park - 9- SAF true servant.
Fletcher - 6- Our only defensive mid, but so far, not his best season, we miss him when we needed him.

Obertan* - 3- Go out!.
Bebe* - 2. 5- Go out!.

Rooney - 8. 5- Not a good start with injuries and so on, but that goal against City rate him 10/10! What a comeback from a really true Man UTD player.... We love you Wayne....
Berbatov - 8- Best season of his season so far in the EPL.
Chicharito - 8- Time to shine for Man UTD.
Owen - 5. 5- Time to leave Man UTD.

Saf- 9 - Experience pays!.

Man UTD - 9. 5- If you look all the problem we had, injuries, Rooney transfer saga + Rooney injury, we are still the Champion!
EnziWazza (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Ryan Giggs 2010/2011 statistic
Appearance : 37.... Man united play 57 match in all competition this season till may 14 2011 : 37 premier league, 5 FA cup, 3 Carling Cup and 12 champion league
Goal : 4 (2 epl, 1 FA Cup, 1 champions league)
Assist : 12 (8 epl, 4 champions league)
Yellow Card : 6

This is about all season, not just one or two match, I know ryan shine in last 3 game against chelsea he change that game, but another player had more appearance, assist, goal, average run distance, etc than him this season, if we can remember 1993/94 and 2002/03 season, for me that is the best season for ryan will give him above 9 perfecto
Bigsxc (Manchester United) 3 years ago
He deserves the 9. 5 how many times was he subbed in and had an impact? What about the west ham game? He constantly makes players that are 10 yrs younger look 10yrs older
Bigsxc (Manchester United) 3 years ago
He deserves the 9. 5 how many times was he subbed in and had an impact? What about the west ham game? He constantly makes players that are 10 yrs younger look 10yrs older
Bladecatcher (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Vds - 9. 9 (Could've been 10 but he did make a mistake against West Brom. Sorry )
Pig - 1

Vidic – 8
Evra - 7
O'Shea - 6
Evans - 6
Smalling - 8
Rafael - 8
Fabio - 8
Rio - 7
Brown * - 6

Neville (I'm adding him because he was a part of the team) - 4. 5

Carrick - 7
Anderson - 7
Giggs - 9
Scholes - 8
Gibson - 7
Valencia - 7
Nani - 6 (Yes, I did just give him a 6)
Park - 9
Fletcher - 7

Obertan* - 3
Bebe* - 2

Rooney - 8 (May have started badly, but he's been one of our most important players at the end of the season)
Berbatov - 7
Chicharito - 9
Owen - 6

Sir Alex - 10
Maestro7 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Ok time to explain why you gave Nani a 6 altho I think you meant 9
Bladecatcher (Manchester United) 3 years ago
I knew someone would disagree I don't think a 9 is right. He was really important to us at the start of the season but for the second half he has been really poor. Greedy, crosses never beat the first man and just takes too long to make decisions. I stick by my word but hopefully he can be consistent next season. He's definitely nearly reached his potential though
ManUK (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Vds - 9
Pig - 3

Vidic – 9
Evra - 7
O'Shea - 6
Evans - 5
Smalling - 6. 5
Rafael - 7
Fabio - 6. 5
Rio - 8
Brown * - 6

Carrick - 8
Anderson - 6
Giggs - 8
Scholes - 7
Gibson - 5. 5
Valencia - 8 (for the time he's been on the pitch)
Nani - 8
Park - 8
Fletcher - 6. 5

Obertan* - 3
Bebe* - 1

Rooney - 7. 5
Berbatov - 8
Chicharito - 8. 5
Owen - 5
Roo10ney (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Vds - 9
Pig - 6

Vidic – 9
Evra - 8
O'Shea - 7
Evans - 7
Smalling - 8
Rafael - 7
Fabio - 8
Rio - 8
Brown * - 7

Carrick - 8
Anderson - 7
Giggs - 9
Scholes - 7
Gibson - 7
Valencia - 8
Nani - 8
Park - 9
Fletcher - 8

Obertan* - 6
Bebe* - 5

Rooney - 9
Berbatov - 8
Chicharito - 9
Owen - 7
Maestro7 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
I think you mean  Rooney - 9  Berbatov - 9*  Chicharito - 9  Seeing that Berba is or top scorer and all
Wayne (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Season is not over, but these are my current ratings....


Vds - 8 The great dutch wall.
Kuz - 4 He's game in blackburn doesn't show any ambition, but leaving the team. Good bye.

Vidic – 8 The usual Serbinator.
Evra - 7 Had he's moment, but good overall.
O'Shea - 7. 5 Very good covering all kinds of defensive positions. Hell, even Center Mid against Arsenal!
Evans - 6 Terrible spell nearly the whole season, but made a good comeback.
Smalling - 7. 5 Would give young player of the year. (21 or lower age)
Rafael - 7
Fabio - 8
Rio - 7
Brown * - 5

Carrick - 7
Anderson - 7
Giggs - 8 The usual.
Scholes - 7
Gibson - 6
Valencia - 7 Deserves more than that, but was gone for a while due to injury.... So 7.
Nani - 8 Too many assist....
Park - 8 Nothing have gone wrong with Park this season. He was December, March's (or was it april?) man of the match.
Fletcher - 7 Had a great spell till he got a virus.

Obertan* - 6 Very good champion league performance, but that's it.
Bebe* - 5 Need to eat less and train more stamina. See him getting tired easily.

Rooney - 7 I can only give Rooney 7 because he started waking up a bit too late.... But he's performance has been superb.
Berbatov - 8 Top of the goal scorer for a while. Making a comeback against Blackpool was a fantastic.
Chicharito - 8. 5 ­Deserve it.
Owen - 5. 5 Might have been a sub player, but very dangerous at time to time....
Kayteo (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Don't see why you're all hating on bebe. He's 20, he's played about 6 games, he's got a couple of goals and he was relatively cheap. He'll take time to develop.

I like how some of you said smalling 6 - because he hasn't played many games, bebe's played fewer and scored goals, and yet you feel comfortable rating him 0 or whatever. Silliness.
Smalling is a 9.
Bebe 5 or 6
EnziWazza (Manchester United) 3 years ago
He is quite expensive for players who play in second division mate
REDDevil98 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Actually when people rating they don't just look how many goals a player score, but they look into the overall aspect/ contribution that player help the team throughout the game
Kevinmw1 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Vds -8 what a brick wall he was, he saved our butts many times. Sad to see him leave
Kuz- 5 wasnt a disaster but also nothing special, had a couple good moments but not enough to keep him.

Vidic –9 solid season again, best defender in the epl for sure.
Evra -7 did well, but not his usual reliable self like last season where I would rate him a 9. After the world cup he kinda struggled to find top form.

O'Shea -7 he did what he needed to do, he was an excellent sub and am glad to had a versatile defender like O'Shea he is a keeper.

Evans - 3 all he did was make stupid decisions and foul, after previous seasons I expected more but this season was a let down.
Smalling -8. 5 He is shaping up to be a great replacement for Ferdinand, I look forward to seeing this kid play. Exceeded expectations.
Rafael - 7 had good season, confirming his spot as a starter for me
Fabio -8 stepped up and became a good sub, he is developing really well.
Rio - 7 strong as usual consistent player, had some injury troubles hence the 7
Brown * - 4 he doesn't know how to defend at this level

Carrick -6-8 he was inconsistent sometimes he was great others he was lost
Anderson - 7 he had a good season, doubled his goals in one game, I think he could be a regular sub.
Giggs - 9 love this guy he was great this season, a backbone in our weakish mid
Scholes - 7 had a great start to the season, but he is old and barely played. He should probably retire
Gibson - 4 Darren Who? I am not a fan of this guy, sure he can hit a rocket, that only goes in once every 50. And most of the times I saw him play he gave up the ball really easily.
Valencia - 6 tough that he broke his leg that really sucks, but he came back and played like he didn't miss a beat. My prolbem with him is his inability to use his left foot. Fix that and he could be 10x better.
Nani -9 What a year, most assists in the epl and had a mix of good goals, he was phenomenal. My one problem is that he dives too much and complains about fouls too much.
Park -8 solid player, this season made me like him, before I hated when he played but he did really well this season.
Fletcher -5 only becuase he was sick most of the time. Hopefully next year he is fit

Obertan* - 4 didn't see him to anything, for all I know he didn't even play
Bebe* -5 he is ok, I think we need to wait on this player for a couple of years.

Rooney -8 weird season for him, started slow and had a transfer scare, but the second half to the season he slowly approached his in form self.
Berbatov -10 finally! He became the player we bought him for, the only problem is SAF didn't play him enough. Our top scorer barely played.
Chicharito - 10 the best buy of the season, this guy exceeded expectations, he was the young player of the year in my book.
Owen - 7 rarely played but he got some goals, I enjoy having an experienced player on our bench
Bjarni10 (Manchester United) 3 years ago
Vds - 9 He was fantastic at times and made some crucial saves in many games. One that sticks out is the one against Chelsea in the Champo League where he saved the header from Torres.

Pig - 4 Showed this season that he is not a worthy replacement for Edwin.


Rafael - 6 Was most of the time very good but injuries followed him all season
O'Shea - 7 Was solid all season. But still doesn't have the pace to keep up with our fast paced wingers.

Fabio - 7 Had a great season. His first really in the first team for most of the season and showed he is just as good as his brother.

Evra - 8 Started very slowly but grew stronger with each game and was reliable as usual.

Brown - can't really grade him since he didn't play much this year. Looks likely he is leaving this summer. If so he has been a great servant for the club.

Evans - 5 Was good in some games but horrendous in other games. Really hope he can pull it together next season since he has got great potential.

Smalling - 7 Great debut season for the lad. Played in some big games but made it through most of them.

Ferdinand - 7 Injuries have taken its toll on old Rio but he still gives some solid performances that keep him as one of the best defenders in the world.

Vida - 9 Brilliant, Outstanding, Fantastic. These are just some of the words to describe what a great season this man had. He truly is the best defender on the planet.



Fletcher - 6 Started the season very well but drifted a bit later on and missed a lot through illness.

Carrick - 7 Had a decent season but still something is missing from his game.

Ando - 7 Injuries were his main problem this season BUT in the latter stages he was fantastic. He is adding goals to his game witch is fantastic and hopefully there is more to come.

Gibson - 5 Never really impressed me this season. Just against Schalke in the second leg but still he was meh this season.

Scholes - 8 He was fantastic the first few months of the season but drifted a bit later on in the season. Sad to see him retire but we can't hang onto him forever.

Giggs - 8 Really good season from him. Often was the creative spark we needed at times this season.

Valencia - 8 He gets this grade just for the way he played in the final few months of the season. Really is weird how he came back so strong and fit after such a horrific injury.

Park - 8 The best we have seen from him in his whole United career. He was not just an fantastic worker running everywhere over the pitch he also scored some great goals.

Nani - 9 The way he has turned his United career around is fantastic. Assisting to so many goals and scoring so many himself. Brilliant season maybe just overshadowed a bit by his diving. But hopefully he can learn a bit and stop.


Berba - 9 I am so delighted that he scored so many goals this season and showed that he is a great player. And I hope he stays and fights for his place.

Chicharito - 9 This boy is a natural goalscorer. Absolute bargain and I hope he continues to score goals for United for many many years.

Rooney - 8 Started the season by shocking us all by wanting to leave. But came back and proved he is one of the worlds best. So lets hope he can keep it up next season and the season after that.

Owen - 6 Was injured for a lot of the campaign and didn't really get many chances in the first team. But still scored some fine goals



   
Kick4Life - changing lives through football