I always asked myself once Ronaldo left, who will be given the task to take our penalty kick in a game. Any idea?

I think it should be Micheal Carrick as he has been the most sucessful pentaly taker so far. Ryan Giggs failed during the community shield

Hmm tough question, I say Roonney or Carrick. Nani is young and Berbatov missed during the FA cup, so he might not take one

Giggs or Rooney!

Untied have plenty of options from the spot (granted they have lost the last two shoots outs, I guess it's down to whos on the pitch as the options are Giggs, Scholes, Carrick, Rooney, Anderson, Owen, Sicknote (when he makes it off the physios table...

Giggs is my hero, but i'd like to see rooney taking them. Rooney needs to have an awesome year, and I think he will. It would also help me in the fantasy league.

Rooney  

Rooney or Gigss, Carrick is defintely someone to consider too

Rooney first choice and why not Ownen, he defientely will have a good year and will score goals

I think Sir Alex Ferguson was testing players for pentaly kick during the community shield. Evra is defeitnety out of the equation. I say Rooney or Nani

Rooney or Giggs. Owen will do also, but it's only his first year in Manchester

I know I will be unpopular for this, but I think we should give berbs another shot, he used to be one of the great penalty takers at Tottenham, he's very composed and accurate, he just messed up big time at the FA cup final. Failing that I think Rooney or Giggs

Berbatov is a good idea but I think he himself is not confident of taking a penalty kick after he missed one in the FA cup and what he is going through. The guy is trying to build some confidence in himself and get more support from the fans. Once hs starts scoring more and more goals and I'm sure he will this season, then he might be given the nod as first choice penalty taker

Quite a big problem for MAN UTD in the cup matches that might includes penalty.... We have seen how MAN UTD lose Community Shield recently.... Ermm, without Ronaldo, Tevez.... I choose Anderson but he is not regular player.... I just list down the players with capability, depends who on the pitch:

1) Anderson
2) Rooney
3) Giggs
4) Carrick
5) Nani
6) Gibson

Yup, I have missed some one:    Owen and Hargreaves can be considered