I wouldn't say so, Petrucci and the Keane brothers should have a shout, but everyone has their own opinion, I agree with you though

I don't even classify Evans as a young player, he's been here and in the picture for so long. He seems mature

I don't class jonny as a young player anymore myself, but it was not me that set the age limit.... Lol, that's why I started my comment "if its 23".
See dgrant117 for verification.... Lol

I know he has matured over the years on the senior team, but he still is in the age limit of a young player. Next year he won't be for sure since he will be 24, but for now he is still classified as it. Let's not get this too technical now.... Lol.

Besides, isn't Sergio Aguero 23 and he's nominated as PFA Young Player of the Year? Why not give Evans a shout?

Well, now this argument is invalid thanks to Jonny being 24, sorry guys. What a slip up. Might need to change your vote Tony

Evans is not 23 or younger, so he cannot be voted for. I apologize for the mix-ups

Evans was 23 when the season started though, so he can be young player of the year

Only one or the other lol, that doesn't count