It would be much more informative if you guys explain in a few words why do you like one above the others

I would like to see Martin Tyler

Ted Williams gets my vote

Shebby Singh or Steve McMahon

I would say Jamie Redknapp, yes he can be annoying sometimes.... But I still like him and will take him over everyone else!

He, like Paul Scholes, is irreplaceable.    But I call on Martin Tyler or Jon Champion to take/ move up.

There can be no doubt about it. Andy gray is a world class pundit. That scottish voice bellowing out "ooooh yerrrr beauty" or "yeeeh dooont save those" will never be forgotten. Gray has been at sky fr 20 years, he could have been to broadcasting what ferguson is to management. But grays arrogance got the better of him and he slipped up.

Should he be replaced by the boring (i'd rather watch paint dry) alan smith? Or the dreary craig burley & chris waddle? Andy townsend, gabby logan, bookies favourite jamie redknapp are mentioned. Will lineker, motty, hansen or shearer have their heads turned by a big money offer from sky? The there ae candidates like ian wright & jonathan pearce who are both international class pundits IMO.