Just got this news, its still a rumor but more of a possibility.




The reason they are stating this likelihood is because Benzema on one hand is not getting enough first team play, whereas Valencia are in financial crisis so they have to sell Silva. So any of you think this might workout?

Not really. I thought United were having financial troubles too...

Yes, they do have financial troubles too but David Gill, the CEO of United did say that funds from Ronaldo's transfer would be made available to Sir Alex. So you never know

Well. I suppose I can see one of the two, but certainly not both

Benzema could be outta' there. He has been watching hiquain score fabulous goals from the side lines, so you never know.

For silva, no idea lol. Gonna' be preety expensive though, he gets paid a f**k load at valencia

I don't think this deal will happen. Silva is a great player, Man United could do with him although Nani's been in stunning form. Benzema needs to get more first team football but then where would Berba or Owen go. And I don't think rooney would work with him well

I dunno but one of the two would be awesome. At this point we need more depth, If Rooney gets injured we're dead

If Manchester United get Benzema there is no way I would want him to get before berbatov. That would just be a waste of good talent like they have now. He would be a good fit and I'm sure him and Rooney would work together.... At least better than what they have now

I think David Silva should go to Liverpool, he would shape things up a bit there more than it would help Manchester United...

I think if we were to get just one of either, it would be more advisable to get Benzema rather than Silva. Benzema would ease alot of pressure from rooney and allow him to play his natural game. Silva on the other wouldn't be needed as of now because Nani and Valencia both are in good form and to add to it Gibson is getting some 1st team time too

Benzema is overrated. So I don't think he will help united. They should keep Rooney. Then play a forward 3 of Valencia Rooney Nani/Park. But Silva would be a great addition

United will have the money to make transfers. I wouldn't be surprised to see neither of these deal go through. Benzema would be a good signing, but I'm sure he'd much rather more of a guarantee of first team football. While I'm sure he would get games with United, he might not get as many as he would want. Remember Tevez.... If only he wasn't owned by a businessman. Anyway, I'd love to see Benzema paired with Rooney to see if they can work together.

Silva would be an extraneous signing for United. We've got a lot of quality in the wings:
-Nani is finally hitting his form.... Finally
-Valencia has been delivering quality crosses all season, once he learns to finish he'll be a monster on the wings
-Obertan is a youngster playing for our reserves and looks to be very promising.
-Giggsy is old but still quality, though he's been in a bit of a rut recently
-Park is a hard worker always

Anyway, that's enough to prove my point. He'd be a good signing, of course, to have on the bench but a completely unnecessary/expensive one

I think benzema actuley played quite well for madrid in the few chances he got to play. It's just the problem is hiquain is playing exceptional and is on such a rich vain of form their is no real room for Karim Benzema. I hope he does not move beacasue I think he could be a real succes at madrid if he was given a descent chance to shine