Forums / Borussia Dortmund
Order: Newest / Oldest
Borussia Dortmund Chat
Gonzaga101 (Borussia Dortmund) 2 days ago
Good win for the pokal
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 2 days ago
Yeah. And typically, Auba misses 4 sitters(3 of them in the post)....

On the bright side, Mor is doing great and I already love Guerreiro

Though, I wonder -- why does Tuchel keep playing Ramos on wing? I mean come on, the guy has no clue how to play there, it's simply not his position. And not only that, but there is Pulisic that could get in instead of him as he could use some playing time (especially since he won't get to play much later in the season I guess).
Gonzaga101 (Borussia Dortmund) Yesterday
Yea I agree on ramos.... Maybe because he is more expensive than Pulisic?  
UWMike (Borussia Dortmund) 5 days ago
Season hasn't even started and another knee surgery for Durm :\    That guy has terrible luck
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 week ago
So.... A loss which was hard to swallow only for the great team performance*, although there are more positives to take than negatives.

Pros:

-Bartra was terrific*. I didn't expect the guy to play like this but damn, if he continues this level he'll prove to be an absolute bargain. His passing and build-up play today was on Hummels-top-form level. Also very solid, along with Sokratis.

-Rode was also great*. He expertly bossed the midfield and halted many counter-attacks. I'm now officially in no doubt that he'll be a hit

-Great team performance*. I loved how we squeezed Bayern so hard in the first half and we could've easily eased past them if only we finished 1/3 of our chances, damn.

-Passlack was also great*. We may be looking at Piszczek's successor here, and the guy's only 18 years old(yes, I know it's way too early to say this, but still)

Cons:

-Schmelzer. He was really off his usual self today. Offered little when attacking and was always a defensive liability whenever Bayern was on the ball. Can't wait to see Guerreiro, though.

-Our f*cking finishing. I can't stress enough how painful it is to miss so much chances in such a match. I hope Schurrle can relieve the pain a little, though

I probably missed some things but that's all I have on my mind at the moment. Also, congrats Bayern, it'll be an exciting season.




*until we conceded the goal
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 week ago
Yeah, we deserved more than a dry 0-2. I think we're looking solid, apart from the finishing as you mentioned.

Really happy to see Bartra doing so well too
Gonzaga101 (Borussia Dortmund) 1 week ago
Rode really impressed me, box to box!
Bavaria (Bayern München) 1 week ago
Great game guys. This dortmund teams looks very strong and you were unlucky not to score in the first half. Don't think you should be disappointed, it was just supercup
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 week ago
I'm still disappointed not because of a lost trophy or game or something, but because of our as-always poor finishing. I don't know what is it with these guys, but they can't finish for their life. That's the main problem of our squad and I don't see how we can deal with it. I hope Schurrle can ease it a bit, though
UWMike (Borussia Dortmund) 2 weeks ago
Boring draw against Sunderland. Still lots of work to do. Looks like defending set pieces is going to be just as big, if not an even bigger problem than it has been. We literally have no height at all in the centre of the park. Our only hope is Bender or Ginter, otherwise we're basically going to lose 100% of header battles. Doesn't look great.

Mor is looking good though. He was basically at the centre of every one of our attacks in the second half
Cloudst (Footytube Mod) 3 weeks ago
So uh how you guys lining up this season seems like you're pretty stacked up
UWMike (Borussia Dortmund) 3 weeks ago
My guess at Tuchel's first 11:

--------Auba--------
Reus---Gotze---Schurrle
----Weigl----Castro----
Guerreiro--Sokratis--Bartra--Piszczek
-------Burki--------

Dembele to start while Reus is still injured. I expect to see heavy rotation at the start of the season with Kagawa/Schmelzer/Durm/Ginter/Rode all getting good minutes. Mor, Pulisic, Merino will probably be reduced to substitute roles with maybe a chance of starting in the early rounds of the DFB Pokal. Same for Ramos, but that much everyone already knew. Leitner to be sold or loaned again. Same for Kuba (unfortunately). Passlack back to the reserves. The only one I have no idea about is Sahin. I can't see him being sold, but I also don't see him playing much
DortmunderJung (Borussia Dortmund) 3 weeks ago
-------Auba------
Reus---------Dembele
--- Götze -Castro----
-------- Rode ---------
Guer. --Papa--Bartra--piszu
-----------Bürki

In offense and midfield we've plenty of options. I think there will be a hell of rotation.

In some bundesliga matches I would like to see sth like this....


------Dembele------
Reus---Götze-- -Mor
--Weigl--Merino--
Guer. - Papa- Bartra Passlack
Bürki
DortmunderJung (Borussia Dortmund) 3 weeks ago
I'm pretty delighted about our signings. Espacially dembele and mor could be the little extra quality we need. In the near past I had the feeling that our players lost the ability to win dribblings and were passing all time. To create space I think, we need beside fast passing game also players, who can leave behind 1-3 players. That's what I missed last season. Reus seemed to lost his faith and ability to dribble. That's why I am totally excited about dembele/mor.
Hopefully the system doesn't change their way to play too much
OddSpud (Borussia Dortmund) 3 weeks ago
@DortmunderJung

You would pick Rode over Weigl as first choice?
Weigl was a revelation last season. He should absolutely be first choice the way I see it
Gonzaga101 (Borussia Dortmund) 3 weeks ago
----------Auba-----------
Reus---Gotze---Dembele---Schurrle
----------Weigle---------
Schmeltzer--Papa--Bartra----Lukas
----------Burki--------
DortmunderJung (Borussia Dortmund) 2 weeks ago
@OddSpud

Weigl is a decent player but still needs to improve his defence skills. I'm sure he will gain this in the future and will be a very important player. But atm I would pick Rode over Weigl. He really impressed me in all pre-season matches. Beside his denfense qualitity he also has vision and is able to make through balls.

In particular we set up our team with offense players like reus, götze, auba, schürlle, kagawa, dembele and mor we need a strong man in front of our defence. Otherwise we will be run over in critical moments. It's just my pov.

KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 2 weeks ago
" But atm I would pick Rode over Weigl. He really impressed me in all pre-season matches.... "

Sure. Let's pick Rode on the basis of 3 matches against not fully fit opposition. Not like Weigl had a great season or something, he was basically second-fiddle or a rotation squad player at most and wasn't really important for us

"we need a strong man in front of our defence.... " The most surprising thing about Weigl last season was that he actually WAS very strong -- even at such a young age and being that skinny in comparison to the others, he fought for the ball and it was very very hard to take it off him.

I'd put Weigl over Rode.

And the ideal squad for me would be....

-------------------Auba----------

Reus-----------Gotze------------Dembele

-------Castro--------------Weigl--------

Guerr. /Schme. --Bartra/Gint. -Sock-Piszczek

------------------Burki------------------
DortmunderJung (Borussia Dortmund) 2 weeks ago
"Let's pick Rode on the basis of 3 matches against not fully fit opposition"

I judge Rode on the basis of his performance in Frankfurt and Bayern. In addition to that it was impressing which amount of impact he had in this pre-season matches - even at such little time with the squad.



KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 2 weeks ago
Ah well, okay then.... Can't argue against that since I really haven't seen him play too much (though I've seen him in some matches for Bayern). I could only argue that I'd surely make Weigl a guaranteed starter if the decision was up to me based on what I have seen from him.



DortmunderJung (Borussia Dortmund) 2 weeks ago
We will see what happens. I'm not too sad if you're right about Weigl. I like this player very much!

Overall we're set up very good, also in depth. Maybe the defence is a little unsettled. But I'm looking forward to the new season
OddSpud (Borussia Dortmund) 4 weeks ago
I really hope Auba is sold next year. I wish he silent already been sold and was replaced
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 4 weeks ago

What I thought about this:

Yeah, I thought what he said was disrespectful. Like, okay, we get it once, it was your childhood dream to join Real Madrid and you promised your grandfather. But to keep repeating and repeating it....

What I think about this now:

I'm not quite sure about what to think now -- after Auba posted the message on his Instagram.

His message is written in really poor English, which probably means he didn't waste any time to make sure it's well-written but simply rushed to write it. I'd say the reception to his interview wasn't very good.

He mentions 'transforming words' but I'm not sure how could anyone 'transform' something so concrete -- that his dream is Real and he promised his grandfather.

He also says "and in any interviews I was honest with you to say that it was my dream since I'm young but not more. " What the heck? Anyways, thanks for the confusion....

UWMike (Borussia Dortmund) 4 weeks ago
Meh, if he only stays one more season and we get at least 60m for him next summer I probably won't complain.

And yea. I don't get why he needs to keep repeating this over and over again
[account-removed] 3 weeks ago
60m? How many times will you sell your main players for dirt cheap? Gungodan for £20m, Mkhi for.... 30m?

With the current trend in the markets you guys can easily get €80m+ for him!
UWMike (Borussia Dortmund) 3 weeks ago
In case you haven't noticed, all of those players that have left for "dirt cheap" only had 1 year remaining on their contracts. So it was either that or lose them for free a year later. That's how numbers work.

As for Auba, next year he'll be 28, not exactly young for a striker who's main asset is speed. I'm sure if we sold him now we could get €80m, but next summer that depends on how his season goes
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 3 weeks ago
I'm not sure that we will sell Auba anytime soon to be honest. Atleast not it is true that he would only leave BVB for Real(they are pretty well stacked with strikers, having Benzema -- at about Auba's age and Morata who is much younger).

I can't see him leaving for clubs like Arsenal (Wenger won't spend), Chelsea (they have Costa and Batshuayi), Liverpool(same reason), Man Utd(same reason) and countless others.

In short, no one needs a striker
[account-removed] 3 weeks ago
Oh, did both of them have only 1 year remaining? I didn't know that, sorry. But then you guys deserve more money for quality players.... Longer contracts maybe?
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
Watzke said no more new signings will be unveiled this summer; so the rumours of us signing Mario Gómez seem to be untrue. Good; we have plenty of players, but I do feel the striker position could've used a great backup like him
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
I think we're fine with Adrian Ramos. I kinda started to like the guy after he started scoring
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
Haha, what a coincidence!

I liked Ramos way before it was cool though I remember he destroyed us in 2012 (perhaps a bit sooner or later) with Hertha and I was impressed what kind of total striker he was. Turns out I was watching him at his very best, his technique isn't fantastic, but I still think he is underrated
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
Also, do you think Pulisic will be sent on loan this season? I mean, Reus and Schurrle are our first-choice wingers, and even without them you've got another pair in Mor and Dembele.

He must be a little bit disappointed to see us signing so much wingers after he had a decent debut season(especially for a 17 year-old)
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
I have no idea TBH. He's too young for a loan to be a must. Personally, if I were Tuchel, I'd sit with him and ask him what he wants himself by telling him the truth: being happy with his progress last season as the coach, but not being able to promise him a lot of playing time this time around.

I would like to see him at Mainz one season
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
"Personally, if I were Tuchel, I'd sit with him and ask him what he wants himself by telling him the truth: being happy with his progress last season as the coach, but not being able to promise him a lot of playing time this time around. ".... #JeroenforBVBCoach (after Tuchel leaves)

On a more serious note though, yeah, I think he could do great in Mainz(or any not-top-seven Bundesliga club for that matter). I think he should be loaned if Tuchel has no plans to play him in more than 2 matches this season. Damn Wolfsburg, why did you sell Schurrle...
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
What do you guys think of Ginter? I mean, our RB position is filled, our DM position is filled and our CB position is also filled.

I wonder how will Tuchel play him (maybe rotating with Bartra/Sokratis but then there is also Bender there....). I hope we don't sell him because he's talented and has many years ahead of him
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
Selling Ginter would be madness; he was one of the best performers last season, and that too in a variety of positions.

I don't know why he wouldn't start ahead of any of our others CBs in the RCB positions. Subo has been out of it for so long in the past years and I think Ginter is better than anyone else in the team in that position now. And who's to say he won't be playing as a RB often? No guarantees Lukasz will always be fit and Durm isn't quite as good as Ginter IMHO either.

Imho:
RB: Piszczek>Ginter>Durm>rest
CB: Subo>Ginter>Sok>Bartra>rest

Plenty of times Matthias will get the chance to start games I think; knowing our injury prone squad
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
I think playing Ginter on RB kinda leaves us very weak on the right side. Note that we now won't have Mikhi who was THE ever-reliable winger when defending. And not to mention that playing Ginter on RB vs stronger teams like Leverkusen, Bayern and the European teams = suicide. I know, he's great when attacking but he's too slow for a RB IMO.

On the CB position, the problem is that you also have Bender, who signed until 2021. Now, I don't think he would sign knowing he's 4th choice. Also you have Bartra who comes from Barcelona because of lack of playing time. Also you have Sokratis who is very solid. And I don't rate Ginter really highly on CB....

But yeah, Ginter will probably get lots of playing time because of injuries.

Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
Well, let's see what Tuchel has in store for us. Bartra might be the first choice along with Ginter, who knows? Youth first?
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
We'll certainly have to wait, but I can't do so without overthinking the possiblities before

Though, I think it might be Sock-Bartra partnership, with Ginter and Bender occasionally rotating with them(before important matches, vs weaker opponents, DFB Pokal etc.)

OddSpud (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
Well chosen mhiki.... Pffff  
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
Lol. At least he scored. But yeah, we are definitely the better team, for now. Doesn't mean a player can't try to join to the club of his dreams. United is still a more prestigious club, but their current state as a team is poor.

I can't imagine them not becoming a lot stronger quickly though. Look at all the players they're hauling in. Typical Mourinho: spend a few hundred million, win a title or two over the course of a few years
SoccerIsFootbal (Manchester United) 1 month ago
Dembele and mor looked good, will be keen to watch their development over the seasons. Smart to get gotze and shurrle to shield some of the young forwards, give them space to grow. I think your squad looks stronger in attack this season despite losing mkhi and gundogan but I suppose time will tell
OddSpud (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
If only football was about how good your club is at present time and not about how good another club was in its past
SoccerIsFootbal (Manchester United) 1 month ago
Relax guys, as I recall you lost 4-0 to liverpool last pre-season. It's just a friendly
UWMike (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
^ That was 2 pre-seasons ago.... And we all know how the rest of that season went.    -_-    
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
That was two seasons ago. And we all know how that went....

It is indeed just a friendly, but you can't deny that one can draw positives and negatives from such a match(other than fitness).

I, for one, have been totally amazed by Dembele and Mor and this match totally solidified my confidence in them. They're gonna' be a smashing hit. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if Schurrle became second fiddle to Dembele.

Also, I've been really skeptic about signing Rode and I'm not gonna' scream all of a sudden "he's THE NEW iniesta" or something but my view of him improved (even though he was playing against not very fit players, yeah, I know).

Also, Bartra looked solid and Weidenfeller didn't make a horrific blunder(that surprised me).

On the other side, Depay is proving to be a signing worth every single pound of the 5 million spent on him. The rest 20 were a waste of money

KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
   
UWMike (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
Yea, not sure we needed both Gotze AND Schurrle....

A midfield of Reus - Kagawa - Gotze, rotating with Dembele, Mor, Pulisic, and Castro? That sounds plenty deep to me.

I'm more concerned about the holding midfield roles. Weigl and? Sahin? Bender (I'm convinced that Tuchel wants him at CB for some reason)? Maybe Ginter? Are we hoping that Merino just walks into that spot? That central-defensive part of the park is a big question mark for me.
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
Man, we've made so much signings that we slowly start forgetting them....  Rode
UWMike (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
:$    Dammit. You got me
SKool (Arsenal) 1 month ago
Aliko (Barcelona) 1 month ago
I know that many fans are just pissed off with Götze but the good thing is: he is back!
Hope he can flourish again under Tuchel. BVB will rock next season!
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
I don't think a lot of fans are really angry he's back, more like in doubt what to expect. And of course it tears open an old woubd, but perhaps so it can heal properly
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
What if Götze was just holding back the whole time at Bayern, spying for us, adding strong laxatives to the Bayern players' food all the time to keep them 'injured'? And now he's back, with a €12m net profit.


Welcome back, traitor. You better redeem yourself.

Best thing about him is that Reus will be happier and eager to stay
Kazuki (Liverpool) 1 month ago
So.... Is this like getting back with your ex. Who left for a rich guy?
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
Your ex of whom you always thought she was the one, who made you a better person and vice versa. And then she left you for that arrogant rich guy all girls want for some reason, who then ditched her in turn because there was zero chemistry between them
Fabiusmaximus (Bayern München) 1 month ago
Got a nice team there fellas, eh?  Can't wait for the season to begin
Jeroen (Barcelona) 1 month ago
I just hope the players 'click' and we'll be spared of countless injuries.

Also, when will you guys sell Hummels to us again? They all return one day, you know
KristijanT (Borussia Dortmund) 1 month ago
Not before he scores in our first clash of course (They all score, you know)
Chellen (Arsenal) 1 month ago
Gotze is a done deal.... Happy you snatch him.... Yes I understand he is considered as a "Judas" but he return, so the best thing for your club and player you will need to support him in order for him to regain his top form, and to make that transfer not a waste.... Then imagine if he can score in a champions league Final and with his assist or goal he can make your beloved team to win that champions league Cup, would you say no because he is a judas or yes? So hope your team continue to progress with those signings!Cheers



   
Kick4Life - changing lives through football